For homemade chicken pot pies, the Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam is my best overall pick for buyers who want a dedicated pie-making format, while the FineMade Electric Mini Pocket Pie Maker stands out for its included crust cutter and the CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker for small individual portions. The main choice is between a compact appliance that makes several smaller pies and a model whose format better suits your preferred crust and serving size. Included cutters and accessories can save prep time, though they do not replace checking whether the cavities fit your recipes. I ranked these six around chicken pot pie practicality, ease of use, and how clearly each model suits a different cook. Continue reading for the full breakdown and a buying guide to help match a maker to your kitchen.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- Pie Magic by Sunbeam takes the overall spot because its dedicated pie-maker identity makes it the clearest fit for shoppers focused on pies rather than a general kitchen appliance.
- FineMade pairs an electric mini pocket pie format with a crust cutter, which may simplify shaping but still calls for checking portion size against your meal plans.
- CucinaPro and MasterChef both emphasize mini pies and quiches, making them natural options for individual servings instead of one large family pie.
- Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 is listed as a four-piece maker, so buyers should weigh its multi-piece format against the counter space and batch size they actually need.
- Aoruru joins the mini pie and quiche options, but the product name alone gives less detail about its distinguishing accessories or capacity; confirm those specifics before choosing it over more clearly described models.
| FineMade Electric Mini Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter |  | Best for Pocket Pies | Brand: FineMade | Capacity: Up to 3 pocket pies | Pocket pie size: 4.5 x 2.5 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 4-Piece Pie Maker, Red |  | Best for Mixed Mini Pies | Brand: Sunbeam | Model: FPSBPMM980 | Capacity: 4 pies | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker |  | Best for Batch Cooking | Brand: CucinaPro | Capacity: Up to 6 mini pies or quiches | Wattage: 980 W | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker |  | Best for Guided Crust Prep | Capacity: 6 mini pies or quiches | Mini pie diameter: 2.75 inches | Dimensions: 2 x 10 x 4 inches (as listed) | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam |  | Best for Quick, Flexible Meals | Brand: Sunbeam | Model: 4805 | Wattage: 1000 watts | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Aoruru Electric Pie and Quiche Maker |  | Best Compact Pick | Brand: Aoruru | Capacity: Up to 4 pies or quiches | Wattage: 800 watts | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| chicken pot pie maker | Brand | Capacity | Dimensions | Wattage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FineMade Electric Mini Pocket | FineMade | Up to 3 pocket pies | 9.5 x 9.5 x 3.8 inches | — |
| Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 4-Piece Pie | Sunbeam | 4 pies | — | 1400 watts |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche | CucinaPro | Up to 6 mini pies or quiches | 10.5 × 4 × 10 inches | 980 W |
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche | — | 6 mini pies or quiches | 2 x 10 x 4 inches (as listed) | — |
| Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam | Sunbeam | — | 9.61 x 10.59 x 5.12 inches | 1000 watts |
| Aoruru Electric Pie and Quiche | Aoruru | Up to 4 pies or quiches | — | 800 watts |
More Details on Our Top Picks
FineMade Electric Mini Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter
The FineMade suits cooks who want portable, hand-held pot pies rather than individual pies for a plate. It makes up to three 4.5 x 2.5-inch pocket pies per batch, and the included crust cutter helps portion dough for its small cooking wells. Compared with the Sunbeam FPSBPMM980, which bakes four mini pies at once, FineMade trades one serving per batch for a pocket format that works well for snacks or packed lunches. Its 750-watt power and compact footprint keep the appliance easy to store, while the nonstick surface simplifies cleanup after savory fillings. The main limitation is capacity: these pies are small, so it is a poor match for anyone expecting a full-size pot pie or cooking for a crowd.
Pros:- Makes up to three pocket pies at once
- Crust cutter helps size dough for the wells
- Nonstick surface supports easier release and cleanup
- Compact dimensions make storage straightforward
Cons:- Small pocket size limits filling and portion size
- Three pies per batch may be slow for group meals
- Requires a 120-volt outlet
Best for: Cooks making small hand-held pot pies for snacks, lunches, or a few servings at a time
Not ideal for: Families who want larger individual pies or need to serve many people in one batch
- Brand:FineMade
- Capacity:Up to 3 pocket pies
- Pocket pie size:4.5 x 2.5 inches
- Power:750 watts
- Voltage:120 volts
- Dimensions:9.5 x 9.5 x 3.8 inches
- Coating:Nonstick
- Included accessory:Crust cutter
Our verdict“Choose FineMade if you want compact, hand-held pot pies and can work with small batches.”
Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 4-Piece Pie Maker, Red
The Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 is a flexible pick for households that want to alternate chicken pot pies with quiches or dessert pies. Its four mini-pie wells give it an edge over the FineMade pocket-pie maker when serving plate-sized individual portions, though it makes fewer at once than the six-well CucinaPro. Power and ready-to-bake lights make it easier to see when the appliance is heating and ready, while the included pastry cutter and pie press help shape crusts. The tradeoff is a fixed four-pie batch, so larger gatherings call for repeated rounds. Its 100-volt specification is also unusual compared with common 120-volt appliances, so buyers should check outlet compatibility before choosing it.
Pros:- Makes four individual mini pies in one batch
- Can prepare pot pies, quiches, and dessert pies
- Indicator lights show power and ready-to-bake status
- Includes pastry cutting and pie press tools
Cons:- Four-pie capacity may require multiple batches for groups
- 100-volt specification may not match common household outlets
- Mini pies are not a substitute for a full-size pot pie
Best for: Households that want one appliance for occasional pot pies, quiches, and dessert pies
Not ideal for: Cooks serving larger groups or anyone who needs a clearly specified 120-volt appliance
- Brand:Sunbeam
- Model:FPSBPMM980
- Capacity:4 pies
- Wattage:1400 watts
- Voltage:100 volts
- Weight:7.2 pounds
- Coating:Non-stick
- Included components:Pastry cutting tool and pie press tool
Our verdict“Pick this Sunbeam if you value varied mini-pie uses and four portions per batch, after checking voltage compatibility.”
CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker
For cooks who want several individual servings from one round, the CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker offers the lineup’s largest stated capacity: up to six mini pies or quiches. That gives it an advantage over the four-well Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 when preparing food for a family or small gathering. Its PFAS-free nonstick ceramic interior is designed to release baked crusts with less sticking, and the included dough cutter helps keep pastry portions consistent. At 4.2 pounds, it is also lighter than the Sunbeam. The compromise is that these are small pastries, not full meal-sized pies, and the appliance takes dedicated counter and storage space. Choose it for batch size and easy crust handling, not for oversized portions.
Pros:- Six-well capacity makes more portions per batch than the four-well Sunbeam
- PFAS-free ceramic nonstick interior aids release
- Dough cutter helps portion pastry consistently
- Compact appliance weighs 4.2 pounds
Cons:- Small pastries may not satisfy buyers seeking full meal-sized pies
- Requires storage for a separate electric appliance
- Limited warranty details are not specified in the supplied product data
Best for: Families or small gatherings that need several mini pot pies or quiches in one batch
Not ideal for: Cooks who want full-size pot pies or prefer to use an existing oven rather than store a dedicated appliance
- Brand:CucinaPro
- Capacity:Up to 6 mini pies or quiches
- Wattage:980 W
- Dimensions:10.5 × 4 × 10 inches
- Weight:4.2 pounds
- Interior:PFAS-free nonstick ceramic coating
- Included components:Pie tin and dough cutting circle
- Warranty:Limited warranty
Our verdict“Choose CucinaPro when six small portions per batch matter more than full-size pies or oven flexibility.”
MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker
The MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker is a six-well option for cooks who want help getting started with individual pies. Its included manual with instructions and recipes gives it a more guided entry point than the CucinaPro, which also makes six mini pies but lists a dough cutter without a recipe manual. The MasterChef’s 2.75-inch pie diameter makes the portion size clear: these are bite-sized servings, useful for snacks or a spread of small dishes rather than a stand-alone family dinner. A nonstick interior and dough-cutting circle support easier release and more consistent crust sizing. Product dimensions are listed as 2 x 10 x 4 inches, so the supplied measurements may not give buyers a dependable sense of its storage footprint.
Pros:- Makes six individual pies or quiches at once
- Recipe manual offers guidance for new mini-pie makers
- Dough-cutting circle helps size crusts
- Nonstick interior supports release and cleanup
Cons:- 2.75-inch pies are bite-sized rather than meal-sized
- Listed dimensions may be unreliable for storage planning
- Limited to mini pies and quiches
Best for: Beginners who want recipe guidance and a tool for shaping small individual pies
Not ideal for: Cooks who need meal-sized pot pies or rely on precise appliance dimensions for storage planning
- Capacity:6 mini pies or quiches
- Mini pie diameter:2.75 inches
- Dimensions:2 x 10 x 4 inches (as listed)
- Item weight:4.29 pounds
- Interior:Non-stick
- Included accessories:Dough-cutting circle and manual with recipes
- Model:MTF-MPB-740
Our verdict“Choose MasterChef for guided preparation of bite-sized pies, but check the appliance’s actual dimensions before planning storage.”
Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam
The Pie Magic Pie Maker fits cooks who want savory pies alongside quiche, fruit tarts, and pizza in the same compact appliance. The product description says it bakes in ten minutes or less, a useful distinction from the FineMade, which emphasizes pocket pies and gives no stated cooking time. Two dough cutters help shape crusts, and a cord wrap keeps storage tidier than a loose-cord appliance. Its single cooking setting keeps operation simple, but offers little adjustment for different recipes. The supplied data does not state how many pies it makes per batch, which makes it harder to compare serving capacity with the six-pie CucinaPro or MasterChef. Buyers should choose it for varied uses and compact storage, not for a known high batch count.
Pros:- Product description states cooking takes ten minutes or less
- Supports pot pies, quiche, fruit tarts, and pizza
- Two dough cutters help shape crusts
- Compact design includes a cord wrap for storage
Cons:- Only one cooking setting limits adjustment between recipes
- Batch capacity is not specified in the supplied product data
- 1000-watt power may be less suited to larger pies
Best for: Cooks who want a compact appliance for quick pot pies plus other savory and sweet dishes
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a confirmed number of servings per batch or variable cooking settings
- Brand:Sunbeam
- Model:4805
- Wattage:1000 watts
- Number of settings:1
- Dimensions:9.61 x 10.59 x 5.12 inches
- Weight:4 pounds
- Included components:Dough cutters
- Material:Polycarbonate
Our verdict“Choose Pie Magic for quick, varied small dishes and compact storage if its unspecified batch capacity works for you.”
Aoruru Electric Pie and Quiche Maker
The Aoruru suits cooks who want four small pies at once without dedicating much storage space to a countertop appliance. Its 800-watt design is described as cooking pies or quiches in a few minutes, which can make quick individual portions more practical than baking a full-size pie. The nonstick plates also reduce cleanup effort after pastry and filling have cooked.
Compared with the FineMade Electric Mini Pocket Pie Maker, whose included crust cutter is aimed at shaping dough, the Aoruru’s appeal is its compact storage and straightforward setup. That simplicity comes with a tradeoff: it has one setting, so cooks have little control over how it heats, and its plastic construction may feel less substantial than a metal-bodied alternative. Choose it for occasional, small-batch pies; skip it if you need adjustable cooking or larger portions.
Pros:- Makes up to four bite-size pies or quiches at once
- Designed to cook pies in a few minutes
- Nonstick coating makes the plates easier to clean
- Compact size is convenient to store
Cons:- One setting offers no cooking adjustment
- Plastic construction may feel less substantial than metal alternatives
Best for: Cooks in small kitchens who want to make up to four bite-size pies or quiches per batch and store the appliance away afterward
Not ideal for: Bakers who want adjustable heat settings, larger pies, or a more substantial metal-bodied appliance
- Brand:Aoruru
- Capacity:Up to 4 pies or quiches
- Wattage:800 watts
- Voltage:110 volts
- Settings:1
- Coating:Nonstick
- Material:Plastic
- Included components:Waffle plates
- Warranty:Limited
Our verdict“Choose the Aoruru for compact, quick batches of small pot pies, but look elsewhere if adjustable cooking matters to you.”
How We Picked
I ranked these makers by how directly their stated format supports chicken pot pie cooking, how useful the named accessories and serving style appear for home preparation, and how easily a buyer can understand the appliance’s intended role. Dedicated pie makers and models with a clear mini pie format offer a more legible fit for this roundup than products whose name gives fewer details. I also weighed likely kitchen tradeoffs: smaller individual pies can simplify portioning, while multi-piece designs may require more counter and storage space.
The ranking favors clear fit and useful distinctions over claims that cannot be confirmed from the product names. The Sunbeam Pie Magic leads as the most explicitly pie-focused option; FineMade follows for its named crust cutter, then CucinaPro and MasterChef for their mini pie and quiche format. Sunbeam’s four-piece model and Aoruru remain relevant alternatives, but buyers should verify their cavity size, included parts, and care instructions before purchase.
| chicken pot pie maker | Brand | Coating | Included components |
|---|---|---|---|
| FineMade Electric Mini Pocket | FineMade | Nonstick | — |
| Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 4-Piece Pie | Sunbeam | Non-stick | Pastry cutting tool and pie press tool |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche | CucinaPro | — | Pie tin and dough cutting circle |
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche | — | — | — |
| Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam | Sunbeam | — | Dough cutters |
| Aoruru Electric Pie and Quiche | Aoruru | Nonstick | Waffle plates |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Chicken Pot Pie Makers
Choosing a chicken pot pie maker starts with the kind of pie you want to serve and the amount of hands-on prep you are willing to do. I would check the appliance’s format and practical details before treating a product label or accessory as proof that it suits a particular recipe.
Choose a serving size before a machine
Decide whether you want individual pies, shareable portions, or a larger centerpiece before comparing models. Mini formats such as those named by CucinaPro and MasterChef point toward personal servings, which can help with lunch portions or varied fillings. Their tradeoff is that several small pies take more shaping and filling steps than one large pie. Check the cavity dimensions and depth, since a pie that looks generous in a listing can still leave little room for chicken, vegetables, and gravy. Avoid assuming a maker’s cavity size from the word “mini” alone. If you cook for a larger household, check how many pies it makes per batch and whether that pace suits dinner.
Check how your crust recipe will fit
Chicken pot pie recipes vary in crust thickness, filling moisture, and whether they use pastry on top, underneath, or both. A pocket-style maker may reward dough cut to a consistent shape, while another design may call for a different approach. A crust cutter, like the one named with FineMade, may make shaping more consistent, but its dimensions should match the maker’s cavities. Thick pastry can crowd out filling, and a wet filling can make sealing harder, so test a small batch before preparing a full meal. Do not assume a machine works with every dough recipe just because it is called a pie maker. Favor a model with clear instructions for dough, fill level, and cooking time.
Treat capacity as a batch-planning question
A multi-piece format can help when you want several portions ready together, but its usefulness depends on how many people you feed and how quickly the appliance cooks. The Sunbeam FPSBPMM980’s four-piece name gives buyers a useful capacity clue, though it does not answer every question about pie dimensions or batch timing. Compare that with mini models by checking actual cavity counts and size rather than relying on names. If you usually cook for one or two, a larger footprint may take up storage space without improving your routine. If you serve a family, consider whether you will need to run multiple batches. Capacity affects serving timing as much as it affects output.
Look beyond the included cutter
Accessories can reduce prep work, but they matter only when they solve a step you actually find tedious. FineMade names a crust cutter, while other product names do not identify an included shaping tool. Before buying, confirm what comes in the box and whether the cutter handles both the top and bottom crusts you plan to make. A dedicated cutter can help keep pastry sizes consistent, but it does not measure filling or prevent overstuffing. Also check whether replacement or alternative cutters are available if you want to use different dough sizes. For a first-time buyer, simple instructions may be more useful than a longer accessory list.
Plan for cleanup and storage
Pie filling and pastry can leave residue around seams and cooking surfaces, so maintenance deserves attention before purchase. Read the care instructions to learn whether the plates are removable and what cleaning tools are safe. A fixed cooking surface may take less setup but can be harder to clean around edges. Measure the appliance’s storage footprint, including room to open its lid, before choosing a maker for a small kitchen. Check cord storage and whether the unit can be stored upright only if those details matter in your space. A compact appliance that is awkward to clean may see less use than a slightly larger one with a simpler care routine.
Compare claims with the details you can verify
Product names establish a rough purpose, but they do not settle questions about wattage, nonstick coating, safety features, or dishwasher-safe parts. Verify those specifications in the current listing and manual before deciding. This is especially useful for Aoruru, whose name signals pie and quiche use without describing a special accessory or capacity. Check warranty coverage and support information as well, since an electric appliance depends on working controls and heating components. Spend more only when a confirmed feature changes your cooking routine, such as a better-matched capacity or easier cleanup. A long feature list is less useful than one or two details that fit your kitchen and recipes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a mini pie maker handle a full chicken pot pie meal?
It can make a meal-sized portion for some diners, but “mini” does not specify a standard serving size. Check cavity width and depth, then compare them with the amount of filling your recipe uses. A smaller cavity may work well for lunch or sides but require multiple pies for dinner. The CucinaPro and MasterChef names identify mini pie formats, so I would verify dimensions before treating either as a family-dinner solution. Also check whether the filling needs to be cooked before it goes into the maker.
Should I choose individual pies or a larger pie format?
Individual pies make portioning simple and let you vary fillings, but shaping several crusts takes more preparation. A larger pie format can suit a shared meal, though it may be less flexible for different dietary preferences. Check the actual cavity layout and output count for each machine because product names may not reveal the full serving format. If you often freeze portions, individual pies can be easier to package separately. For a single household meal, choose based on how you serve dinner rather than the number of cavities alone.
Does an included crust cutter make a pie maker a better choice?
A cutter can save time when it matches the appliance’s cavity dimensions and the dough style you use. FineMade specifically names a crust cutter, giving it a clear prep accessory advantage over products whose names do not mention one. Still, the accessory does not tell you whether the maker is the right size or how easy it is to clean. Check whether the cutter shapes the full set of crust pieces you need and whether it is included with the version for sale. If you already own suitable cutters, the accessory may matter less than capacity and storage.
What should I check before using a new maker for a wet filling?
Look for manufacturer guidance on filling preparation, maximum fill level, and whether ingredients should be cooked before assembly. Chicken pot pie filling can contain substantial moisture, which may affect sealing and crust texture. Start with a small batch and avoid filling to the rim until you know how the lid closes. A recipe designed for a standard oven pie may need less filling or a thicker sauce when adapted to smaller cavities. Confirm cleaning guidance as well, since spills around the edges can be difficult to remove if allowed to cool.
Which details should I verify when a listing gives few specifications?
Confirm the cavity dimensions, number of pies per batch, power requirements, included accessories, and cleaning instructions. These details affect whether the maker suits your recipes and whether it will fit your kitchen routine. Aoruru’s product name indicates pie and quiche use but does not identify a distinctive capacity or accessory, so I would compare its full listing with the more clearly named options. Check the manual or manufacturer page when the retailer description leaves gaps. Warranty and support information can also help you judge an electric appliance with limited published detail.
Conclusion
For the clearest dedicated pie-making fit, I would start with the Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam as the best overall choice. The FineMade is my best pick for buyers who want a named crust cutter to support shaping, while CucinaPro suits cooks prioritizing mini individual pies. For a beginner, I would favor whichever of those models has the clearest instructions and cavity dimensions in its current listing; the product names alone do not establish ease of use. The Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 may suit buyers who want a four-piece format, and Aoruru is worth comparing when its full specifications match a particular kitchen need. Treat “best value” and “best premium” as feature-fit decisions here: without verified package details, I would not assign either label based on price or assumed build quality. Match the maker’s portions, prep tools, and cleanup demands to how you make chicken pot pie, then confirm those details before ordering.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
