Choosing the best Guinness beer depends heavily on whether you crave traditional stout bitterness or a smoother, lower-alcohol profile. For most drinkers, the Guinness Draught Stout remains the gold standard for its balanced flavor and creamy texture, while the Guinness Extra Stout offers a bolder, more robust experience for stout purists. The primary tradeoff lies in alcohol content and intensity; Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic provides the iconic taste without the buzz, though it lacks the full body of its alcoholic counterparts. This guide breaks down the nuances between cans, bottles, and ABV levels to help you select the perfect pint.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- Guinness Draught is superior for smoothness due to its nitrogen widget, which creates a cascading effect that Extra Stout cannot replicate in bottles.
- Extra Stout delivers higher bitterness and alcohol content, making it better for sipping slowly rather than session drinking.
- Guinness 0 has improved dramatically in recent years, offering a close approximation of the original taste for designated drivers or health-conscious drinkers.
- Canned Draught varieties generally offer better freshness and portability compared to bottled versions, which can be sensitive to light.
- Pack size impacts value significantly; larger packs of Guinness 0 often provide better cost-efficiency for regular consumers than single-serve bottles.
| Guinness beer | Pack Size | Can Size | Ingredients | Brand |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guinness Draught Stout Beer | 4 cans | 14.9 fl oz | — | — |
| Guinness Extra Stout Beer | 6 bottles | — | — | Guinness |
| Guinness Extra Stout | 6 bottles | — | Malted barley | — |
| Guinness Extra Stout | — | — | — | Guinness |
| Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draug | 4 cans | 14.9 oz | Water, barley, hops, and yeast | Guinness |
| Guinness Draught | 6 bottles | — | — | Guinness |
| Guinness Draught Irish Stout B | 8 cans | 14.9 fl oz | Pale malt, flaked barley, roasted barley, hops | — |
| Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draug | 5 cans | 14.9 oz | Water, barley, hops, yeast | — |
| Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draug | 10 cans | 14.9 oz | Water, barley, hops, yeast | — |
| Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draug | 12 cans | 14.9 oz | Water, barley, hops, yeast | Guinness |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Guinness Draught Stout Beer, 4-Pack, 14.9 fl oz Cans
This option stands out for its nitrogenating widget, which replicates the creamy head and smooth texture of a tap pour. Unlike the Guinness Extra Stout bottles, which lack this internal mechanism, the Draught cans deliver the signature surge-and-settle effect right in your hand. The 4.2% ABV makes it sessionable, offering balanced notes of coffee and chocolate without overwhelming bitterness. However, the smaller 4-pack size means you must restock more frequently than with larger formats. It is ideal for those who prioritize the authentic sensory experience over bulk convenience.
Pros:- Nitrogen widget creates a smooth, draft-style pour with a lasting creamy head.
- Balanced flavor profile with distinct roasted coffee and chocolate notes.
- Lower ABV allows for easier sipping over longer periods.
Cons:- Requires specific pouring technique and settling time for best results.
- Smaller pack size may lead to more frequent grocery trips.
Best for: Drinkers who want the authentic tap-style presentation and creamy mouthfeel without visiting a pub.
Not ideal for: High-volume consumers who prefer buying in larger 6-pack or 12-pack quantities to save shelf space and money.
- Pack Size:4 cans
- Can Size:14.9 fl oz
- Alcohol Content:4.2% ABV
- Beer Style:Draught stout
- Color:Dark ruby red
- Flavor Notes:Bitter, sweet, and roasted notes with hints of coffee and chocolate
- Nitrogenating Widget:Yes
Our verdict“Choose this if you value the ritual and texture of a perfect Guinness pour above all else.”
Guinness Extra Stout Beer, 6-Pack, 12 fl oz Bottles, 5% ABV
This six-pack offers a standardized entry point into the Guinness lineup. Compared to the Guinness Draught cans, the Extra Stout lacks the nitrogen widget, resulting in a flatter head and a drier finish. The 5% ABV provides a slightly stronger kick, appealing to those who find the Draught too mild. While the 12 fl oz bottles are easier to store than the bulky 22 oz single bottles, they require careful pouring to avoid excessive foam. This is a practical choice for everyday drinking where the specific nitrogen sensation is less critical than consistency.
Pros:- Convenient six-pack format balances quantity and portability.
- Slightly higher ABV than Draught offers more body and warmth.
- Standard bottle size fits easily in most refrigerator door shelves.
Cons:- Lacks the nitrogen widget for a creamy head.
- Can feel drier and less smooth than the Draught version.
Best for: Regular drinkers who prefer a slightly higher alcohol content and standard bottle formats.
Not ideal for: Purists who demand the creamy, cascading head found only in Draught or tap versions.
- Brand:Guinness
- Style:Extra Stout
- Pack Size:6 bottles
- Bottle Size:12 fl oz
- Alcohol by Volume:5%
- Dimensions:7.5 x 5 x 8.25 inches
- Item Weight:7.1 pounds
Our verdict“This pack is the sensible choice for those who drink Guinness regularly but don’t need the fancy widget.”
Guinness Extra Stout, 6-Pack, 11.2 fl oz Bottles
This variant distinguishes itself with more aggressive hopping and pronounced dark cherry notes. When compared to the Guinness Draught Stout, this Extra Stout is less about creamy smoothness and more about robust, bitter complexity. The 5.6% ABV is the highest among the standard six-packs, delivering a fuller mouthfeel. However, the smaller 11.2 fl oz bottle size feels slight compared to the standard 12 oz options. It suits drinkers who enjoy a drier, more bitter profile and are willing to trade some volume for intensified flavor depth.
Pros:- Heavier hopping provides a crisp, bitter counterpoint to the roasted malt.
- Distinct dark cherry and roasted malt flavor profile.
- Higher ABV offers a richer body than standard Draught.
Cons:- Small 11.2 fl oz bottles provide less volume per serving.
- Bitterness may be too intense for beginners or sweet-toothed drinkers.
Best for: Palate-driven drinkers who prefer strong hop bitterness and fruity dark malt characteristics.
Not ideal for: Those who prefer a sweeter, smoother, or more sessionable stout experience.
- Pack Size:6 bottles
- Bottle Size:11.2 fl oz
- Alcohol by Volume:5.6%
- Ingredients:Malted barley
- Flavor Notes:Roasted malt, dark cherries
- Serving Suggestion:Pour cold into a room-temperature glass
- Comparison:More heavily hopped than Guinness Draught
Our verdict“Pick this if you want a bolder, more bitter Guinness with complex fruity undertones.”
Guinness Extra Stout, Single Bottle, 22 fl oz, 7.5% ABV
This single bottle is an outlier due to its 7.5% ABV and large 22 fl oz volume. Unlike the Guinness Extra Stout 6-Pack, which is designed for casual consumption, this bottle demands respect and pacing. It delivers an intense, warming experience with deep roasted flavors. The tradeoff is obvious: it is a single unit, making it impossible to share casually or stock for a party. It is best suited for solitary enjoyment or special occasions where the high alcohol content and substantial serving size are desired features rather than drawbacks.
Pros:- High 7.5% ABV provides significant warmth and intensity.
- Large 22 fl oz bottle offers a generous serving size.
- Distinct from standard sessionable stouts, offering a premium feel.
Cons:- Single-bottle format limits sharing and variety.
- High ABV makes it difficult to drink multiple servings safely.
Best for: Experienced stout drinkers seeking a potent, high-ABV experience in a large format.
Not ideal for: Groups or social settings where sharing is preferred, or those sensitive to high alcohol content.
- Brand:Guinness
- Product type:Extra Stout
- Packaging:Single bottle
- Volume:22 fl oz
- Alcohol by volume:7.5%
- Format:Bottle
- Intensity:High
Our verdict“This is a niche pick for those who want a strong, solo sipping experience.”
Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draught Stout, 4-Pack, 14.9 oz Cans
This product redefines what a stout can be without alcohol. Using cold filtration, it retains the dark color and creamy head of the standard Guinness Draught Stout. The flavor profile remains balanced with chocolate and coffee notes, though it lacks the warming alcohol bite. The 4-pack format mirrors the standard Draught, making it easy to swap into your routine. It is the ideal choice for designated drivers or health-conscious drinkers who refuse to compromise on the sensory experience of a Guinness, despite missing the ethanol content entirely.
Pros:- Cold filtration preserves the smooth character and dark color of traditional Guinness.
- Maintains a creamy head and balanced chocolate/coffee flavor profile.
- Alcohol-free without sacrificing the iconic brand identity.
Cons:- Lacks the alcohol warmth and body of traditional stout.
- Includes non-beverage items like a phone holder that may clutter packaging.
Best for: Designated drivers, pregnant women, or anyone avoiding alcohol who still wants the Guinness ritual.
Not ideal for: Drinkers who specifically crave the warming effect or body provided by alcohol.
- Brand:Guinness
- Product Type:Non-alcoholic draught stout
- Pack Size:4 cans
- Can Size:14.9 oz
- Alcohol Content:Alcohol-free
- Brewery:St James’s Gate
- Ingredients:Water, barley, hops, and yeast
- Alcohol Removal Process:Cold filtration
Our verdict“This is the top choice for enjoying the Guinness experience without the alcohol.”
Guinness Draught, 6-Pack, 12 fl oz Bottles, 4.2% ABV
This six-pack offers a classic glass-bottle presentation that appeals to those who prefer traditional packaging over aluminum. Compared to the Guinness Draught Irish Stout Beer, 8-Pack, these smaller bottles are easier to handle and store in crowded fridges, though they lack the nitrogen widget found in the cans. The 12 fl oz size provides a manageable pour, making it suitable for casual drinking without committing to a larger volume. However, without the nitro widget, the head may not be as creamy or persistent as its canned counterparts. This option makes the most sense for traditionalists who value the ritual of pouring from glass.Pros:- Classic glass bottle presentation
- Compact 12 fl oz size for easy storage
- Standard 4.2% ABV for a balanced drink
Cons:- Lacks nitrogen widget for creamy head
- Smaller volume per serving compared to cans
Best for: Drinkers who prefer glass bottles and smaller serving sizes for casual evenings.
Not ideal for: Those seeking the signature creamy nitro head found in canned versions.
- Brand:Guinness
- Pack Size:6 bottles
- Bottle Volume:12 fl oz
- Alcohol by Volume:4.2%
- Total Volume:72 fl oz
- Item Weight:7.1 pounds
Our verdict“Choose this if you prefer the tactile experience of glass bottles and smaller servings.”
Guinness Draught Irish Stout Beer, 8-Pack, 14.9 fl oz Cans, 4.2% ABV
The inclusion of a nitrogen and carbon dioxide blend sets this pack apart, delivering the signature cascading pour and creamy head that define Guinness. Unlike the Guinness Draught, 6-Pack Bottles, these cans use a widget to replicate the tap experience at home. The larger 14.9 fl oz size offers more beer per can, providing better value for volume. However, the aluminum packaging may not appeal to those who dislike the metallic taste transfer sometimes associated with cans. This pick is ideal for purists who want the closest match to a pub pour.Pros:- Nitrogen widget creates authentic cascading pour
- Smooth, creamy head mimics tap service
- Larger 14.9 fl oz volume per can
Cons:- Aluminum packaging may affect flavor for some
- Heavier total weight due to larger cans
Best for: Fans of the classic Guinness tap experience who want a creamy head at home.
Not ideal for: People who strongly prefer glass bottles over aluminum cans.
- Pack Size:8 cans
- Can Size:14.9 fl oz
- Alcohol by Volume:4.2%
- Style:Irish stout
- Ingredients:Pale malt, flaked barley, roasted barley, hops
- Carbonation:Nitrogen and carbon dioxide
Our verdict“This is the top choice for replicating the iconic Guinness tap pour at home.”
Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draught Stout, 5-Pack, 14.9 oz Cans
This five-pack serves as a low-commitment introduction to Guinness 0, allowing buyers to test the flavor profile before investing in larger quantities. Compared to the Guinness 0, 10-Pack, the smaller size reduces risk if you find the non-alcoholic variant lacks the body of traditional stouts. The cold filtration process aims to preserve chocolate and coffee notes, though some drinkers may notice a thinner mouthfeel. The included tasting notes and recipes add value for those exploring new ways to enjoy the stout. It makes the most sense for curious newcomers to the non-alcoholic beer market.Pros:- Low-risk trial size for new buyers
- Preserves chocolate and coffee flavor notes
- Includes tasting notes and recipe guides
Cons:- May lack body compared to alcoholic versions
- Higher cost per can than larger packs
Best for: Newcomers wanting to try Guinness 0 without a large financial commitment.
Not ideal for: Regular drinkers who prefer the convenience of bulk buying.
- Product type:Non-alcoholic draught stout
- Pack size:5 cans
- Can size:14.9 oz
- Brewery:St James’s Gate
- Ingredients:Water, barley, hops, yeast
- Alcohol removal:Cold filtration
- Extras:Phone/tablet holder; tasting notes
Our verdict“Ideal for first-time buyers who want to sample the non-alcoholic stout before committing.”
Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draught Stout, 10-Pack, 14.9 oz Cans
Balancing quantity and price, this ten-pack offers a practical middle ground for regular consumers who enjoy Guinness 0 as a daily or weekly staple. Compared to the Guinness 0, 12-Pack, it is easier to store in standard refrigerators while still providing enough volume for social gatherings. The cold filtration ensures the stout retains its smooth character and creamy head, making it a respectable alternative to alcoholic stouts. However, the lack of nutritional details on the packaging might disappoint health-conscious buyers. This option is better suited to consistent drinkers who want a balance of convenience and value.Pros:- Balanced pack size for storage and value
- Retains smooth texture and creamy head
- Suitable for social gatherings or daily use
Cons:- Missing detailed nutritional profile
- Still contains barley, limiting gluten-free options
Best for: Regular consumers who drink Guinness 0 frequently and want good value.
Not ideal for: Health-conscious buyers who require detailed nutritional labeling.
- Pack Size:10 cans
- Can Size:14.9 oz
- Style:Draught stout
- Alcohol Content:Non-alcoholic
- Brewery:St James’s Gate
- Ingredients:Water, barley, hops, yeast
- Accessories:Phone holder; tasting notes
Our verdict“The best choice for regular drinkers seeking a balance of price and practicality.”
Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draught Stout, 12-Pack, 14.9 oz Cans
For those who have already committed to the non-alcoholic lifestyle, this twelve-pack offers maximum convenience and reduced frequency of shopping trips. Compared to the Guinness 0, 10-Pack, the larger volume lowers the per-can cost and ensures you are prepared for unexpected guests. The cold filtration process maintains the dark color and balanced bitter-sweet notes, though the flavor may fade slightly if stored for extended periods. The included phone holder is a quirky addition that may appeal to tech-savvy users. This pick makes the most sense for dedicated fans who consume Guinness 0 regularly.Pros:- Largest pack size for best per-can value
- Convenient for hosting and frequent consumption
- Includes unique phone/tablet holder accessory
Cons:- Large volume may lead to waste if unused
- Heavier to transport than smaller packs
Best for: Dedicated fans who consume non-alcoholic stout regularly and want bulk savings.
Not ideal for: Casual drinkers who might not finish the pack before freshness declines.
- Brand:Guinness
- Style:Non-alcoholic draught stout
- Pack Size:12 cans
- Can Size:14.9 oz
- Alcohol Content:Alcohol-free
- Brewery:St James’s Gate
- Ingredients:Water, barley, hops, yeast
- Process:Cold filtration
- Extras:Phone holder; tasting notes
Our verdict“Choose this if you are a committed Guinness 0 drinker looking for bulk efficiency.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these Guinness products based on flavor consistency, mouthfeel, and the balance between traditional stout characteristics and modern brewing innovations. Flavor profile was the primary metric, distinguishing between the sharp, roasted notes of Extra Stout and the creamy, chocolatey notes of Draught. I also considered packaging utility, recognizing that the nitrogen widget in cans significantly alters the drinking experience compared to standard bottles. Finally, versatility played a role, as some options suit casual gatherings better than others, particularly when factoring in alcohol content and serving temperature requirements.
| Guinness beer | Ingredients |
|---|---|
| Guinness Draught Stout Beer | — |
| Guinness Extra Stout Beer | — |
| Guinness Extra Stout | Malted barley |
| Guinness Extra Stout | — |
| Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draug | Water, barley, hops, and yeast |
| Guinness Draught | — |
| Guinness Draught Irish Stout B | Pale malt, flaked barley, roasted barley, hops |
| Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draug | Water, barley, hops, yeast |
| Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draug | Water, barley, hops, yeast |
| Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draug | Water, barley, hops, yeast |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Guinness Beer
Selecting the right stout involves more than just picking a brand name. Understanding the technical differences between brewing styles and packaging methods will refine your choice.
Draught vs. Extra Stout: Understanding the Flavor Divide
The fundamental difference lies in the hop profile and malt balance. Draught is brewed to be smoother and less bitter, relying on nitrogen for a creamy head. Extra Stout contains more roasted barley and hops, resulting in a sharper, coffee-like finish. If you prefer a gentle, dessert-like stout, Draught is the logical choice. However, if you enjoy complex, bitter notes that pair well with dark chocolate or strong cheeses, Extra Stout provides the necessary intensity. Do not assume one is universally better; they serve different palates.
The Impact of Packaging on Freshness and Texture
Packaging dictates the texture of the beer. Cans with widgets mimic the pub experience by releasing nitrogen upon opening, creating the signature cascade and creamy head. Bottles typically use carbonation, which yields a sharper, fizzier mouthfeel. Light exposure is also a factor; clear or green glass can degrade hop compounds, leading to off-flavors. For the freshest taste, cans are often superior because they block light entirely. If you buy bottles, store them in a dark, cool place to preserve the intended flavor profile.
Alcohol Content and Serving Context
ABV levels range from 0% to over 7%, which changes how you consume the beer. Guinness 0 allows for extended social drinking without impairment, making it ideal for lunch hours or designated drivers. Standard Draught at 4.2% ABV suits casual evening gatherings. Extra Stout at 5% or 7.5% ABV is better suited for slow sipping or after-dinner consumption. Matching the ABV to the occasion prevents overconsumption and ensures you appreciate the beer’s complexity without rushing.
Pack Size and Economic Efficiency
Buying in bulk often reduces the cost per ounce, but it requires proper storage space and consumption speed. Larger packs of Guinness 0 are cost-effective for regular drinkers who go through six-packs quickly. Small packs or single bottles offer flexibility for trying new varieties or for one-off occasions. Consider your refrigerator space and drinking habits. If you only drink stout occasionally, a six-pack prevents waste. If it is a staple, larger formats provide better value and convenience.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Guinness Draught and Guinness Extra Stout?
The primary difference is in the bitterness and body. Guinness Draught is smoother, less bitter, and uses nitrogen to create a creamy texture, making it approachable for most drinkers. Guinness Extra Stout has a higher hop content and more roasted malt, resulting in a sharper, more robust flavor with a drier finish. Draught is better for casual sipping, while Extra Stout suits those who prefer intense, coffee-like stout notes.Is Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic actually similar in taste to the original?
Modern Guinness 0 is remarkably close to the original Draught in terms of aroma and color, though the mouthfeel is slightly lighter. The brewing process removes alcohol while retaining the roasted barley flavors, so you still get that familiar chocolate and coffee profile. It lacks the slight warmth and full body of the alcoholic version, but for a non-alcoholic option, it is the most faithful representation available. It is an excellent substitute for social settings where alcohol is not desired.Why do some Guinness cans have a ball inside them?
That small plastic device is called a widget, and it contains nitrogen gas. When you open the can, the pressure change releases the nitrogen into the beer, creating the famous cascading effect and a thick, creamy head. This mimics the experience of a pint poured from a tap in a pub. Bottles do not have this mechanism, so they rely on carbon dioxide, which produces a fizzier, less creamy texture. If you want the authentic pub experience at home, choose canned Draught with a widget.Which Guinness variety is best for cooking?
Guinness Extra Stout is generally better for cooking because its higher bitterness and robust flavor stand up to long cooking times and rich ingredients like beef or chocolate. The sharper notes penetrate meats and sauces more effectively than the milder Draught. However, if you are making a lighter sauce or a dessert where you want subtle stout notes without overwhelming bitterness, Guinness Draught can work well. Avoid using non-alcoholic versions for cooking if you want the depth of flavor that alcohol evaporation contributes.How should I store Guinness to maintain its quality?
Store all Guinness varieties in a cool, dark place away from direct sunlight, which can degrade flavors and cause skunking. Refrigeration is ideal for serving, but unopened cans and bottles can be kept in a pantry if the temperature is stable. Once opened, consume the beer within a day or two for the best taste, as oxidation will flatten the flavor and reduce the head retention. Do not freeze the beer, as this can damage the texture and alter the carbonation or nitrogen release.Conclusion
To summarize, the Guinness Draught Stout is the best overall choice for most people due to its balanced flavor and creamy texture. For those seeking a stronger, more bitter profile, the Guinness Extra Stout is the premium pick. If you need a non-alcoholic option, the Guinness 0 Non-Alcoholic Draught Stout offers the best value and taste fidelity, especially in larger packs. Beginners should start with the Draught 4-Pack to experience the classic smoothness before exploring the intensity of Extra Stout or the convenience of non-alcoholic variants.
