TL;DR
The Kitchn published Julie Laing’s review of Caraway’s 12-piece, five-ply stainless steel cookware set. After daily cooking and hand-washing the pieces, she praised its responsiveness to temperature changes and reported evenly popped popcorn, while noting that the lid holder needs a suitable mounting spot. The supplied report does not include the full review or independent verification of Caraway’s performance claims.
The Kitchn has published a hands-on review of Caraway’s 12-piece stainless steel cookware set, with writer Julie Laing reporting responsive heat control during daily cooking and a successful popcorn test. Her account gives prospective buyers practical details about the pans and their storage system, while also identifying a constraint: the included lid holder needs a suitable cabinet door or wall space.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Laing tested the set by cooking with it daily after putting away her nonstick cookware. Her meals included eggs, oatmeal, soup, grilled cheese, vegetables, tuna, curries, pasta, sauces and poached pears. She also heated pickle brine and fruit for canning. For a more formal check, she fried eggs in the fry pan and hand-washed and dried every piece after use.
The set contains a 10.5-inch fry pan, a 3-quart saucepan, a 4.5-quart sauté pan and a 6.5-quart Dutch oven, along with three stainless steel lids. Caraway supplies a four-piece magnetic organizer for the pans and a canvas holder with three lid slots. Laing says the pans fit in her 24-inch cabinet, and that the organizer was useful beside the stove during a day of recipe development in a larger kitchen.
Laing found that changes to the stovetop setting quickly affected the sound of sizzling and bubbling. She also says popcorn cooked successfully in the Dutch oven using the medium heat Caraway recommends. That is her reported result from her own cooking, not a controlled comparison of cookware performance. The review describes the set as oven- and broiler-safe to 550°F, compatible with gas, electric and induction cooktops, and covered by a lifetime warranty against defects.
Daily Cooking and Storage Trade-Offs
The review speaks to shoppers weighing the convenience of nonstick cookware against the durability they expect from stainless steel. Laing writes that her stackable nonstick pans served her well before showing their age, prompting her to reconsider stainless steel. Her experience suggests what buyers can learn from a hands-on review: how a set handles everyday tasks, responds to heat adjustments and fits into a real kitchen.
Storage may shape the buying decision as much as cooking performance. Laing reports that the pans and magnetic holders fit in a compact cabinet, but the canvas lid holder was harder to place because it needs a full-height cabinet door without middle shelving. She instead used the included adhesive-backed hooks on a kitchen wall and says they held the lids. Kitchens without that kind of door or available wall space may need another arrangement.
The account may help readers form questions about the set, but it reflects one reviewer’s cooking and kitchens. It does not establish how the pans compare with other brands across standardized tests, how they perform over years of use or whether the price is justified for every household.
Products Worth Considering

Instant Pot Duo 6-Quart 7-in-1 Electric Pressure Cooker

Cuisinart FP-130 13-Cup Food Processor, White

Breville Smart Grinder Pro Conical Burr Coffee Grinder, Black Truffle
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Five-Ply Set Is Built
Caraway’s set uses five layers: stainless steel on the outside and inside, with three aluminum layers between them. The company says this construction helps prevent hot spots. Laing also writes that Caraway uses a passivation process on the stainless steel surface; the supplied excerpt describes this as a common process used in high-quality knives and cookware, but cuts off before completing the explanation.
Caraway says the set does not contain PFAS often found in nonstick cookware. Those product and construction statements are attributed to the company in the review. Laing’s testing focused on cooking, heat response, cleaning and storage; the excerpt does not describe laboratory testing of materials or independent verification of the company’s claims.
The set comes with cookware, lids, organizers and a lid holder, rather than a separate pan for every lid. The stated maximum is medium heat on the stovetop and 550°F in the oven or under the broiler. The source says the lifetime warranty covers defects, but it does not provide the warranty’s full terms or list exclusions.
““I couldn’t be happier.””
— Julie Laing, The Kitchn reviewer
Questions the Excerpt Leaves Open
The supplied source ends partway through its description of passivation and does not include the rest of the review. It is therefore unclear whether Laing later discusses other drawbacks, long-term wear, price, or a final recommendation beyond the positive assessment included here. The excerpt also does not provide a publication calendar date; it labels the review as published two days earlier.
Several performance points remain unverified in the supplied material. It contains Laing’s observations, but no side-by-side measurements of heating or cleaning, no long-term durability results, and no independent confirmation of Caraway’s claims about hot spots or PFAS. Full warranty conditions, care instructions beyond the reviewer’s hand-washing routine and current pricing are not included either.
Check the Full Review and Terms
Readers considering the set can consult The Kitchn’s full review for any additional testing, drawbacks and conclusions beyond the excerpt provided. Before buying, they can also check Caraway’s current product listing for price, included pieces, care guidance, compatibility details and the full warranty terms, since the review says its prices were accurate only at publication.
For shoppers focused on fit, the next practical step is to measure cabinet and counter space and check whether the lid holder can be mounted as intended. The available source gives no announced product change or future testing milestone.
Key Questions
What cookware comes in Caraway’s stainless steel set?
The 12-piece set includes a 10.5-inch fry pan, 3-quart saucepan, 4.5-quart sauté pan, 6.5-quart Dutch oven, three lids, a magnetic pan organizer and a canvas lid holder.
How did the reviewer test the pans?
Julie Laing reports cooking with them daily, including eggs, oatmeal, vegetables, tuna, curries and sauces. She also fried eggs in the fry pan and hand-washed and dried every piece after use.
What did the reviewer say about heat performance?
Laing says the pans responded quickly when she adjusted the stovetop temperature. She also reports making popcorn in the Dutch oven at Caraway’s recommended medium heat, with no burned or unpopped kernels in her test.
What storage issue did the review identify?
Laing says the pans fit in a 24-inch cabinet, but the canvas lid holder needs a full-height cabinet door without middle shelving. She used the included adhesive-backed hooks on a wall and reported that they held the lids.
Does the review independently verify Caraway’s claims?
The supplied excerpt reports the reviewer’s cooking experience and attributes construction and material claims to Caraway. It does not describe independent laboratory testing of heat distribution, materials or long-term durability.
Source: rss
