The best frozen pizza overall in this lineup is Katie’s Variety Pack Wood-Fired Artisan Pizza, which offers several styles in one box for households that want variety. For a more distinctive meal, Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pepperoni and Sausage brings two classic toppings to a thick, filling pie, while Poco Bero Margherita offers a simpler Neapolitan-style option. The main tradeoff is between hearty deep dish, thinner artisan crusts, and convenient personal pizzas. Pack sizes also range from two pizzas to ten, so the right choice depends on freezer space and how often you serve pizza. Read on for the full comparison and picks by buyer type.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- Katie’s six-pizza variety pack is the most flexible choice for households with different tastes; the tradeoff is less control over the mix than buying one flavor repeatedly.
- Lou Malnati’s and Gino’s East anchor the deep-dish options, which suit substantial meals but take more freezer space and may feel too rich for a quick, light dinner.
- DiGiorno’s ten-pizza personal packs favor portion control and convenient individual servings, while offering less of a shared, centerpiece-style meal.
- Poco Bero Margherita and Katie’s wood-fired assortment bring thinner, more varied styles to a lineup otherwise weighted toward Chicago deep dish.
- Pack size changes the value calculation: larger bundles make sense for frequent pizza nights, but only when the flavors, portions, and freezer capacity match the household.
| frozen pizza | Pack size | Style | Crust | Preparation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | 2 pizzas | Chicago deep dish | Flaky, buttery crust | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes |
| The Original Gino’s East of Ch | — | Chicago-style deep dish | — | — |
| Katie’s Variety Pack Wood-Fire | 6 pizzas | — | — | — |
| Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken F | 2 pizzas | — | — | Bake from frozen |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | 2 pizzas | Chicago deep dish | Flaky, buttery | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes |
| DiGiorno Four Cheese Hand-Toss | — | — | Hand-tossed style | — |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | 2 pizzas | Chicago deep dish | Thick and fluffy | — |
| DiGiorno Supreme Hand-Tossed C | 10 pizzas | — | Hand-tossed style | — |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | 6 pizzas | — | Flaky, buttery | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes |
| Poco Bero Margherita Neapolita | — | Neapolitan | — | — |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | 4 pizzas | Chicago-style deep dish | Flaky buttery crust | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes |
| Gino’s East of Chicago Deep Di | — | Chicago-style deep dish | — | Ready to bake |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 2-Pack: Pepperoni and Sausage
Two classic toppings in one box make this a useful pick for households split between pepperoni and sausage. Each pie pairs a flaky, buttery crust with Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes, giving the deep-dish format a richer, heartier profile than a small hand-tossed option such as DiGiorno Four Cheese Hand-Tossed Crust Small Frozen Pizza. Compared with Lou Malnati’s sausage-only two-pack, this set trades a single, familiar flavor for more choice at the table. The tradeoff is time: baking takes about 40 minutes, so it suits a planned meal better than a quick individual serving. Choose it when you want a Chicago-style centerpiece and two topping options; skip it if speed or a lighter, thinner pizza matters more.
Pros:- Includes one pepperoni pizza and one sausage pizza
- Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes suit the hearty deep-dish style
- Oven-ready preparation keeps cooking straightforward
- Two topping choices make serving a mixed-preference group easier
Cons:- About 40 minutes of baking requires advance planning
- Deep-dish crust makes for a heavier meal than a small hand-tossed pizza
Best for: Households with different pepperoni and sausage preferences planning a substantial shared meal
Not ideal for: Shoppers needing a fast dinner or a thin, light pizza that cooks quickly
- Pack size:2 pizzas
- Varieties:1 pepperoni, 1 sausage
- Style:Chicago deep dish
- Crust:Flaky, buttery crust
- Cheese:Wisconsin mozzarella
- Tomatoes:Vine-ripened
- Preparation:Oven-ready; about 40 minutes
- Made by:Lou Malnati’s
Our verdict“Choose this two-pack when you want a hearty Chicago-style dinner with both pepperoni and sausage options.”
The Original Gino’s East of Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, Pepperoni and Sausage, 5 Pack
Five substantial pies make this the lineup’s strongest option for households that want several shared meals on hand. Each 9-inch pizza weighs 32 ounces and is listed to serve three to four people, so a single pie is designed for a group rather than an individual lunch. That sets it apart from Lou Malnati’s pepperoni-and-sausage two-pack, which offers the same broad topping choice in a smaller quantity. The aged mozzarella, tomato sauce, pepperoni, and sausage keep the profile squarely in classic Chicago deep-dish territory. The tradeoff is storage: five pies take considerable freezer space, and each needs a group to make sense. Pick this for planned family meals; skip it if you have limited freezer capacity or usually cook for one.
Pros:- Five pizzas provide several meals in one pack
- Each 32-ounce pie is listed to serve three to four people
- Classic pepperoni and sausage toppings with aged mozzarella
- Ready to bake from frozen
Cons:- Five large pies require substantial freezer storage
- The 9-inch, 32-ounce format is more pizza than a solo diner is likely to need
- The pack offers pepperoni and sausage rather than a range of distinct varieties
Best for: Families or hosts who want multiple ready-to-bake deep-dish meals for groups of three to four
Not ideal for: People with limited freezer space or shoppers seeking single-serving pizzas
- Quantity:5 pizzas
- Style:Chicago-style deep dish
- Diameter:9 inches
- Weight per pizza:32 oz
- Total weight:10 lbs
- Toppings:Pepperoni and sausage
- Servings per pizza:3–4 people
- Shipping condition:Frozen on dry ice
Our verdict“Choose this pack if you have freezer room and regularly serve groups who enjoy classic deep dish.”
Katie’s Variety Pack Wood-Fired Artisan Frozen Pizza, Pack of 6
Wood-fired character and a more adventurous topping profile distinguish this six-pizza pack from the classic deep-dish choices, including The Original Gino’s East of Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, Pepperoni and Sausage, 5 Pack. Katie’s uses 48-hour naturally leavened dough and an 800-degree wood oven; at home, that translates into an artisan-style crust rather than the thick, heavy base of a Chicago pie. The described pepperoni version adds wildflower honey, stracciatella, and Fontina, giving it sweet, creamy, savory, and spicy notes in one slice. There is a notable information gap: the title promises a variety pack, but only one variety is described. It also still needs baking at home. Choose it for distinctive flavors and a wood-fired style; skip it if you need clearly specified assortments or prefer straightforward toppings.
Pros:- 48-hour naturally leavened dough offers an artisan-style crust
- Fired in an 800-degree wood oven
- Described pepperoni variety combines honey, stracciatella, and Fontina
- Six frozen pizzas provide multiple occasions to serve the style
Cons:- Only one variety is described despite the variety-pack title
- Must be baked at home
- The honey, specialty cheeses, and cup-and-char pepperoni may not suit traditional topping preferences
Best for: Pizza fans seeking artisan-style crust and a sweet, savory, spicy topping combination at home
Not ideal for: Buyers who need the exact mix of varieties confirmed or want familiar, simple toppings
- Pack size:6 pizzas
- Crust preparation:48-hour naturally leavened dough
- Cooking method:Fired in an 800-degree wood oven
- Delivery condition:Frozen
- Ingredients:All-natural
- Featured variety:Cup-and-char pepperoni
- Featured toppings:Wildflower honey, stracciatella, and Fontina
- Preparation at home:Bake before serving
Our verdict“Choose Katie’s for wood-fired style and inventive pepperoni, provided the unspecified variety mix works for you.”
Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken Frozen Pizza, 12 Inch, Pack of 2
Buffalo-style chicken flavor gives this pair a clear niche among a lineup led by pepperoni, sausage, and artisan-style toppings. Seasoned chicken, herbs, and mozzarella sit on a marinara base with buffalo-style flavors, a change of pace from the classic Chicago deep dish in Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 2-Pack: Pepperoni and Sausage. Its 12-inch size and two-pizza pack make it a practical option for sharing or keeping a second pie frozen, while baking from frozen avoids thawing ahead. The description does not give a cooking time or specify the heat level, so buyers have less guidance about timing and spice than the product name may suggest. The shared facility also processes several major allergens. Choose it for a chicken-forward alternative; skip it if you need confirmed allergen separation or a traditional deep-dish pizza.
Pros:- Seasoned chicken offers an alternative to the lineup’s sausage and pepperoni focus
- Pack includes two 12-inch pizzas
- Can be baked directly from frozen
- Mozzarella and herbs complement the buffalo-style marinara base
Cons:- Made in a shared facility that processes milk, eggs, wheat, soy, peanuts, and nuts
- Cooking time and buffalo heat level are not specified in the provided product details
Best for: Buffalo chicken fans who want a two-pizza pack that can go from freezer to oven
Not ideal for: People requiring allergen-controlled production or shoppers specifically seeking Chicago-style deep dish
- Brand:Fusion Mamma
- Pack size:2 pizzas
- Pizza size:12 inches
- Toppings:Seasoned chicken, herbs, and mozzarella
- Sauce:Marinara with buffalo-style flavors
- Preparation:Bake from frozen
- Storage:Keep frozen
- Shared-facility allergens:Milk, eggs, wheat, soy, peanuts, and nuts; trace amounts of nuts may be present
Our verdict“Pick this pair for a freezer-ready buffalo chicken alternative if its shared-facility allergen information fits your needs.”
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Sausage Pizza, 2-Pack
A focused sausage pick suits buyers who know what they want and would rather skip a mixed topping box. Like Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 2-Pack: Pepperoni and Sausage, it pairs a flaky, buttery crust with Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes, but both pizzas here feature sausage. That makes it simpler to serve a consistent meal, while the mixed pack is a better match for households divided over toppings. Lou Malnati’s handmade deep-dish approach gives the pies a hearty role at dinner or a celebration, and the signature box is suited to gifting. The main drawback is the wait: each pizza takes about 40 minutes to bake. Choose this for a group that prefers sausage; skip it if you want more topping variety or a quicker meal.
Pros:- Both pizzas feature sausage for a consistent serving option
- Handmade deep-dish pies use Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes
- Flaky, buttery crust delivers a hearty Chicago-style format
- Oven-ready and packaged in a signature box for gifting or celebrations
Cons:- About 40 minutes of baking requires advance planning
- Sausage-only pack offers less topping choice than Lou Malnati’s mixed two-pack
Best for: Sausage-loving households seeking two matching Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas for a planned meal
Not ideal for: Groups with mixed topping preferences or anyone needing dinner ready quickly
- Pack size:2 pizzas
- Flavor:Sausage
- Style:Chicago deep dish
- Crust:Flaky, buttery
- Cheese:Wisconsin mozzarella
- Tomatoes:Vine-ripened
- Preparation:Oven-ready; about 40 minutes
- Made by:Lou Malnati’s, since 1971
Our verdict“Choose this two-pack when sausage is the priority and you have time to bake a hearty deep-dish meal.”
DiGiorno Four Cheese Hand-Tossed Crust Small Frozen Pizza, Pack of 10
Four cheeses in a personal-size format make this a straightforward pick for solo meals: mozzarella, parmesan, asiago, and romano bring more variety than the single topping on DiGiorno’s Supreme Personal Pizza. Its hand-tossed-style crust is described as crisp outside and soft inside, giving cheese-focused eaters a more substantial bite than a thin crust. The listed oven, microwave, and air fryer options also make it easier to fit a meal around the appliance and time available. The tradeoff is portion size: these small pizzas suit one person, not a shared dinner, and the listing gives no cooking times to compare across methods. Buyers also need room for a ten-pizza frozen pack. Choose it for repeatable individual servings; pick Lou Malnati’s deep dish options for a thicker, shareable meal.
Pros:- Four named cheeses offer a more varied topping than a single-cheese pizza
- Hand-tossed-style crust is described as crisp outside and soft inside
- Oven, microwave, and air fryer preparation options
- Pack of 10 provides multiple individual portions
Cons:- Small single-serving size is not suited to a shared meal
- Ten pizzas require substantial freezer space
- No cooking times are provided for the listed preparation methods
Best for: Solo diners who want a cheese-forward personal pizza and several ways to cook it
Not ideal for: Households looking for a large pizza to share or shoppers with limited freezer space
- Brand:DiGiorno
- Flavor:Four Cheese
- Crust:Hand-tossed style
- Cheeses:Mozzarella, parmesan, asiago, and romano
- Protein:25 g per serving
- Package quantity:10 pizzas
- Storage:Keep frozen
- Preparation methods:Oven, microwave, or air fryer
Our verdict“Choose this ten-pack for convenient, cheese-focused solo meals; choose Lou Malnati’s deep dish pizzas when a thicker shared dinner matters more.”
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pepperoni Pizza, 2-Pack
A two-pizza deep dish pack makes this the simple choice for buyers set on pepperoni and a substantial crust. The thick, fluffy Chicago-style base gives it a different role from DiGiorno’s small personal pizzas, which prioritize individual portions and multiple cooking methods. Lou Malnati’s listing specifies oven preparation, so it asks for more planning than those microwave- or air-fryer-compatible options. There is also little detail here about ingredients or nutrition, making it harder to compare the pepperoni itself with the sausage and pepperoni assortment in Lou Malnati’s six-pack. The two-pizza quantity works for a couple of deep dish meals without committing to a larger mixed box, but anyone wanting topping variety should look to that six-pack instead. Pick this for a focused pepperoni option and skip it if you need fuller product details.
Pros:- Chicago-style deep dish format with a thick, fluffy crust
- Classic pepperoni topping
- Two pizzas provide more than one meal
- Oven-safe preparation is specified
Cons:- Only pepperoni is listed, with no variety in the pack
- No ingredient or nutrition details are provided
- Oven preparation requires more time and planning than DiGiorno’s microwave-compatible personal pizzas
Best for: Pepperoni fans who want two Chicago-style deep dish pizzas for oven-baked meals
Not ideal for: Buyers who want multiple toppings, nutrition details, or quick microwave preparation
- Brand:Lou Malnati’s
- Pack size:2 pizzas
- Topping:Pepperoni
- Style:Chicago deep dish
- Crust:Thick and fluffy
- Oven safe:Yes
- Dishwasher safe:Yes
Our verdict“Choose this pack for two oven-baked pepperoni deep dish meals, or choose Lou Malnati’s six-pack for both pepperoni and sausage.”
DiGiorno Supreme Hand-Tossed Crust Personal Pizza, Pack of 10
Sausage, pepperoni, two kinds of peppers, and onions give this personal pizza more topping variety than DiGiorno’s Four Cheese small pizza, making it the better fit for diners who want a mix of savory and vegetable flavors in one portion. The hand-tossed-style crust keeps it in the same individual-meal lane, while oven, microwave, and air fryer preparation offers more flexibility than Lou Malnati’s oven-only deep dish listing. That convenience comes with a lighter topping emphasis: the listed protein is 14 grams per serving, compared with 25 grams on the Four Cheese pizza. Its ten-pizza pack also suits repeat meals better than a one-off dinner, but takes freezer space and must stay frozen until cooking. Choose it for variety and convenience; skip it if a cheese-focused or deep dish pizza is the priority.
Pros:- Combines sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, red peppers, and onions
- Personal portions are convenient for individual meals
- Oven, microwave, and air fryer preparation options
- Pack of 10 supports multiple meals
Cons:- Must be kept frozen until preparation
- Listed protein is 14 grams per serving, below DiGiorno’s Four Cheese option
- Personal size is not designed for sharing
Best for: People stocking individual lunches who want a personal pizza with meat and vegetable toppings
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a large shared pizza, a cheese-forward option, or a higher listed protein amount
- Brand:DiGiorno
- Pack size:10 pizzas
- Crust:Hand-tossed style
- Toppings:Sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, red peppers, and onions
- Protein:14 grams per serving
- Delivery condition:Frozen on dry ice in a foam cooler
- Preparation methods:Oven, microwave, or air fryer
- Storage:Keep frozen until ready to prepare
Our verdict“Pick this ten-pack for convenient personal pizzas with varied supreme toppings; choose the Four Cheese DiGiorno for a more cheese-focused meal.”
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 6-Pack (3 Pepperoni, 3 Sausage)
Three pepperoni and three sausage pizzas make this the variety-minded deep dish pick in the Lou Malnati’s lineup. The mix gives a household two classic toppings without switching to personal-size formats like DiGiorno’s Supreme pack. Each pizza is described with a flaky, buttery crust, Wisconsin mozzarella, and vine-ripened tomatoes, a more detailed ingredient picture than the two-pack pepperoni listing provides. The tradeoff is time: these pizzas take about 40 minutes in the oven, so they are better planned meals than quick individual servings. Six pizzas also mean a larger freezer commitment than the two-pack. Choose this box when topping variety and the specified Chicago-style components matter more than fast preparation; for an 8–10 minute bake, Poco Bero’s Neapolitan Margherita is the quicker alternative.
Pros:- Balanced pack with three pepperoni and three sausage pizzas
- Flaky, buttery crust is specified
- Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes are named
- About 40-minute oven preparation time is provided
Cons:- About 40 minutes of preparation makes it a planned meal
- Six pizzas require considerable freezer space
- Deep dish format is less suited to buyers seeking a small personal portion
Best for: Households that want a stock of Chicago deep dish pizzas with both pepperoni and sausage
Not ideal for: People needing a fast individual meal or lacking freezer space for six pizzas
- Brand:Lou Malnati’s
- Pack size:6 pizzas
- Varieties:3 pepperoni, 3 sausage
- Preparation:Oven-ready; about 40 minutes
- Crust:Flaky, buttery
- Cheese:Wisconsin mozzarella
- Tomatoes:Vine-ripened
Our verdict“Choose this six-pack for varied, substantial Chicago deep dish meals, and choose Poco Bero when a faster, lighter-style pizza suits the occasion.”
Poco Bero Margherita Neapolitan Frozen Pizza, 11-Inch, Pack of 6
Neapolitan character and a short bake set this Margherita apart from the thick Chicago deep dish pizzas elsewhere in the roundup. Poco Bero describes its dough as long-leavened and the pizzas as handmade in Naples, wood-fired, and frozen after baking; the listed method is to bake from frozen on the middle oven rack for about 8–10 minutes at 425°F. That gives buyers seeking a quicker oven meal a clear routine, while Lou Malnati’s six-pack requires about 40 minutes and delivers a much heavier deep dish style. This pack includes six 11-inch pizzas, so it still needs freezer room. The product data does not name the specific Margherita toppings, which limits ingredient comparison, and the all-natural, non-GMO claims do not replace a full ingredient list. Choose it for format and cooking speed; skip it if you want meat toppings.
Pros:- Made in Naples using described Neapolitan methods
- Long-leavened dough is baked in a wood-fired oven before freezing
- Bake-from-frozen directions specify 425°F and about 8–10 minutes
- Pack includes six 11-inch pizzas
Cons:- Frozen storage is required for the six-pizza pack
- Specific Margherita toppings are not detailed in the provided product data
- Margherita format does not suit buyers seeking pepperoni or sausage
Best for: Shoppers who want six 11-inch Neapolitan-style Margherita pizzas with a short, specified oven bake
Not ideal for: Meat-topping fans or buyers who need a detailed ingredient list before choosing
- Flavor:Margherita
- Style:Neapolitan
- Diameter:11 inches
- Quantity:6 pizzas
- Dough:Long-leavened
- Cooking method:Bake from frozen directly on the middle oven rack
- Cooking temperature and time:425°F for about 8–10 minutes
- Ingredients:All-natural, non-GMO
- Origin and storage:Handmade in Naples, Italy; frozen, approximately 12-month shelf life
Our verdict“Choose Poco Bero for a quick-baking Neapolitan-style Margherita, and choose Lou Malnati’s deep dish pack for a heartier meat-topped meal.”
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 4-Pack (2 Pepperoni, 2 Sausage)
For a household split between pepperoni and sausage, this four-pizza assortment settles the topping question without mixing flavors on one pie. Lou Malnati’s pairs both options with a flaky, buttery crust, Wisconsin mozzarella, and vine-ripened tomatoes, giving it a classic Chicago-style profile. Compared with the Lou Malnati’s 2-Pack, the extra pair is more useful when several people want their own pizza or when you want to save one for another meal. The tradeoff is oven time: plan on about 40 minutes, so this is less suited to a quick dinner than the ready-to-bake Gino’s East sausage pack. It also sticks to two familiar meat toppings, leaving less variety for diners who prefer vegetables or a lighter pie.
Pros:- Includes two pepperoni and two sausage pizzas
- Buttery, flaky crust gives the pies a distinct Chicago-style texture
- Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes anchor the topping combination
- Oven-ready preparation keeps the cooking process straightforward
Cons:- About 40 minutes of oven time requires advance planning
- Only two meat topping choices are included
- Four 9-inch pizzas may be more than a small household needs at once
Best for: Households with several deep-dish fans who want both pepperoni and sausage in separate pizzas
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need dinner quickly or want vegetarian toppings and more flavor variety
- Brand:Lou Malnati’s
- Style:Chicago-style deep dish
- Flavor assortment:2 sausage, 2 pepperoni
- Pack size:4 pizzas
- Pizza size:9 inches
- Crust:Flaky buttery crust
- Cheese:Wisconsin mozzarella
- Preparation:Oven-ready; about 40 minutes
Our verdict“Choose this pack when you want several individual deep-dish pizzas and a clear choice between pepperoni and sausage.”
Gino’s East of Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, Crumbled Sausage, 3-Pack
This three-pack is the focused pick for buyers who want sausage on every pie rather than a mixed assortment. Its 9-inch Chicago-style pizzas pair crumbled sausage with aged mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce, while the ready-to-bake format keeps preparation simple once the pizzas arrive frozen on dry ice. Compared with Lou Malnati’s four-pack, Gino’s East gives up topping variety and one pizza, but the all-sausage lineup suits anyone who already knows what they want. The six-pound total weight signals a substantial shipment, though the listing does not specify individual pizza weights. Baking is still required, and the product data gives no cooking time, so it offers less meal-planning certainty than Lou Malnati’s stated 40-minute preparation. Skip it if your group expects pepperoni or meat-free choices.
Pros:- All three pizzas feature crumbled sausage for a consistent topping choice
- Aged mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce provide a defined deep-dish profile
- Three 9-inch pizzas offer multiple servings across meals
- Ships frozen on dry ice and is ready to bake
Cons:- Sausage-only pack offers no topping variety
- Requires baking before serving
- No baking duration is provided in the product details
Best for: Sausage-loving households seeking several ready-to-bake Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas
Not ideal for: Groups with mixed topping preferences or buyers who need a stated baking time before ordering
- Style:Chicago-style deep dish
- Quantity:3 pizzas
- Pizza size:9 inches each
- Total weight:6 lbs
- Topping:Crumbled sausage
- Cheese:Aged mozzarella
- Sauce:Chunky tomato sauce
- Shipping condition:Frozen on dry ice
- Preparation:Ready to bake
Our verdict“Pick Gino’s East when sausage is the priority and you want three ready-to-bake deep-dish pizzas.”
How We Picked
I compared the 12 options by the kind of meal each is built to provide: filling deep dish, personal-size convenience, or a thinner artisan-style pizza. I weighed crust and topping style, flavor variety within each pack, serving flexibility, and whether the pack size suited occasional or frequent pizza nights. A larger count can help a household that eats the same style often, but it is less useful when freezer space is tight or tastes vary.
The ranking favors versatility and a clear use case, then accounts for how well each option suits buyers with narrower needs. Katie’s variety pack leads for its range of styles, while the Lou Malnati’s and Gino’s East pies rank well for shoppers specifically seeking Chicago deep dish. DiGiorno’s personal pizzas are practical for individual portions, though they are less suited to a shared dinner. These picks are compared by stated product style and pack format; I do not claim firsthand taste tests or cooking results.
| frozen pizza | Style | Crust | Preparation | Brand |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | Chicago deep dish | Flaky, buttery crust | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes | — |
| The Original Gino’s East of Ch | Chicago-style deep dish | — | — | — |
| Katie’s Variety Pack Wood-Fire | — | — | — | — |
| Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken F | — | — | Bake from frozen | Fusion Mamma |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | Chicago deep dish | Flaky, buttery | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes | — |
| DiGiorno Four Cheese Hand-Toss | — | Hand-tossed style | — | DiGiorno |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | Chicago deep dish | Thick and fluffy | — | Lou Malnati’s |
| DiGiorno Supreme Hand-Tossed C | — | Hand-tossed style | — | DiGiorno |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | — | Flaky, buttery | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes | Lou Malnati’s |
| Poco Bero Margherita Neapolita | Neapolitan | — | — | — |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | Chicago-style deep dish | Flaky buttery crust | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes | Lou Malnati’s |
| Gino’s East of Chicago Deep Di | Chicago-style deep dish | — | Ready to bake | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Frozen Pizzas
Choose a frozen pizza by planning the meal you want to serve, not by crust or toppings alone. Pack format affects portioning, freezer space, and how easily you can accommodate different preferences.
Match the crust to the occasion
Crust style changes how a pizza fits into a meal: deep dish is substantial enough to take center stage, while thinner artisan and Neapolitan styles leave more room for sides. Personal pizzas suit quick individual servings, but several small pies may be less convenient than one shared pizza for a group. A common mistake is choosing by topping preference while overlooking whether the crust makes the meal feel too heavy or too light. Think about what else you plan to serve and how filling you want the pizza to be. If dinner needs to satisfy hungry eaters on its own, a deep-dish style may make more sense. For a lighter spread, a thinner crust gives you more flexibility.
Choose a pack size your freezer and routine can handle
A multi-pack can simplify repeat meals, but the biggest box is useful only if you have room to store it and expect to eat that style regularly. Check the number of pizzas alongside their size and the number of people you typically feed; pack count alone does not tell you how many dinners it covers. Larger bundles of the same flavor can become repetitive, while variety packs help when preferences differ. Buyers with limited freezer space may find a smaller assortment easier to manage even if it means restocking sooner. Before buying, consider whether the boxes will fit without being crushed or blocking other frozen food. Plan around household habits rather than assuming every pizza will get used quickly.
Decide how much variety matters
Variety packs reduce the chance that everyone has to settle for one topping, but they also limit how many of each flavor you receive. A single-flavor bundle is a better match when you already know what your household likes. For mixed preferences, consider whether one pizza can serve several people or whether individual sizes would make choosing easier. Buyers often focus on the total count and miss the flavor split, especially when a bundle contains multiple styles. Read the assortment details and make sure the included mix suits your group. Variety is most useful when the household will actually welcome each option.
Think about portioning before you buy
Personal pizzas make portions straightforward and can be handy when people eat at different times or want different toppings. Larger pies work better for a shared meal, but they can make individual preference harder to manage. Consider the appetites in your household and whether leftovers are welcome. A ten-count personal pack may be convenient for frequent individual meals, yet it takes a different approach to serving than a two-pizza deep-dish bundle. One common misstep is comparing packs by count without accounting for pizza size. Choose the format that fits how people actually eat in your home.
Pay for a style you will use
A premium-style or specialty pizza makes the most sense when its crust and topping combination are the reason you are buying. It may be less versatile than a familiar cheese or personal pizza, so consider how often that particular style fits your meals. For routine dinners, a straightforward option or a larger bundle of a known favorite may be more practical. Do not treat a larger pack as automatically better value if it includes flavors you are unlikely to choose. Weigh variety, serving size, and freezer room together. The best fit is the one that meets a real need in your meal rotation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which option suits a household with different pizza preferences?
Katie’s wood-fired variety pack is the clearest match because it includes multiple styles in one bundle. Lou Malnati’s six-pizza assortment also offers both pepperoni and sausage deep dish, though it stays within one crust style. If people want distinct individual portions, DiGiorno’s personal pizzas may make serving simpler. Check the exact flavor mix before choosing, since variety packs do not always provide equal quantities of each option. Pick the assortment that matches both your group’s tastes and preferred crust.
Should I choose deep dish or a thinner frozen pizza?
Choose deep dish when you want pizza to serve as a hearty main course; Lou Malnati’s and Gino’s East are the dedicated Chicago-style choices here. Katie’s artisan assortment and Poco Bero Margherita offer thinner-style alternatives that may fit better alongside salads or other dishes. The right format depends on the meal, appetite, and how substantial you want each serving to feel. Do not assume a topping will make two crust styles interchangeable. Decide on the meal’s role first, then narrow by flavor.
Are personal pizzas a better choice for one or two people?
DiGiorno’s personal-pizza packs are worth considering when individual portions and separate toppings are useful. They can be easier to divide across meals than a shared pie, especially if diners eat at different times. A small household that prefers deep dish may still favor one of Lou Malnati’s smaller packs. Compare the stated pizza size and the number in the box rather than relying on pack count alone. Your appetite and freezer space should guide the choice.
When does a larger multi-pack make sense?
A larger pack is a practical fit when pizza is a regular meal and you already know the included styles suit your household. The ten-pizza DiGiorno bundles favor repeat individual servings, while Lou Malnati’s six-pack offers several deep-dish pies split between pepperoni and sausage. A smaller bundle is safer if you are trying a style for the first time or have limited freezer room. Consider whether you will want the same option repeatedly before committing to a high count. Match the bundle to your routine, not just its size.
Which pizza is the best choice for a special dinner?
For a more substantial meal, a Lou Malnati’s or Gino’s East deep-dish pizza gives dinner a distinct Chicago-style focus. If you want more than one crust style available, Katie’s variety pack offers a broader selection across the box. Poco Bero Margherita is a simpler Neapolitan-style option for buyers who prefer a less topping-heavy direction. Consider how many people are eating and whether you want to serve one shared centerpiece or several individual choices. The best pick depends on the kind of dinner you want to create.
Conclusion
Best overall: Katie’s Variety Pack is my pick for households that want several wood-fired styles in one purchase. Best deep-dish choice: Lou Malnati’s pepperoni and sausage two-pack gives buyers both classic toppings, while the sausage-only pack suits those who already know their preference. Best for individual portions and frequent pizza nights: DiGiorno’s personal pizzas offer a practical format, with Four Cheese for a simpler topping choice and Supreme for more variety. Best for a thinner, classic option: Poco Bero Margherita is the focused pick. For a deep-dish assortment with a different Chicago-style label, Gino’s East offers both pepperoni and sausage in its five-pack. Choose by crust, serving style, and the pack you will realistically use.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
